Values and Criteria in Heritage Preservation
From: Thursday, March 01, 2007  To: Monday, March 05, 2007
  Promoted by:
Romualdo Del Bianco Foundation

in the context of:

  And by:

ICOMOS International Committee for the Theory and the Philosophy of Conservation and Restoration


ICCROM




  S
ponsored by:
Vivahotels Art in our HeArt


Project Leader:
Prof. Andrzej Tomaszewski (ICOMOS International Committee for the theory and philosophy of conservation and restoration)

Description:


The spontaneous and multiaspectual international debate on the philosophical and theoretical bases of the protection of cultural property of the past few years gave rise to the 2005 declaration of the XII General Assembly of ICOMOS in Xi’an. This called into being the International Scientific Committee on Theory and Philosophy of Conservation and Restoration (henceforth ‘ICOMOS Theory Committee’). The main tasks of the Committee were defined in its statute as follows:
The aim of the Committee – consistent with the aims of ICOMOS international cooperation – is to explore the basis and framework of conservation, restoration and preservation theory and practice in the globalising world. Therefore the Committee's role is to analyse and prepare adequate proposals and solutions for up-dated theoretical orientations.
In the framework of its activities in the field of conservation and restoration the Committee may:
- examine the existing corpus of documents and scientific studies;
- identify needs and new areas of interest;
- develop ideas and visions for the future;
- cooperate with other ICOMOS committees and scientific bodies of other institutions (such as UNESCO, ICCROM and ICOM) in order to establish an integrated theoretical basis for cultural heritage preservation.

The first conference organised jointly by the Committee and the International Centre of Culture took place in Cracow in May 2006. Its subject was “Towards a Global Philosophy of Heritage Conservation”.

The next conference is being organized jointly by the ICOMOS Theory Committee, the International Centre for the Study of the Preservation and Restoration of Cultural Property (ICCROM) and the Fondazione Romualdo Del Bianco Florence. It will take place in Florence on 1st - 4th March 2007, and its title is:

VALUES AND CRITERIA IN HERITAGE CONSERVATION

This topic is regarded as important from both the theoretical and practical points of view. The varied and rich range of cultural property values - from aesthetic and artistic to utilitarian, material and technical - is perceived and classified differently in different cultural areas (for reasons which include cultural traditions and religious beliefs). These values also evolve over time and are in fact the criteria on the basis of which cultural property is assessed and action is taken both at the local level in individual cases and in a more universal context, for example in inscribing monuments on the UNESCO World Heritage List. A further issue is the relationship between the values of the historical monument being considered, the surviving historical values and those which are produced (added?) as a result of the activities of the conservator (the aesthetics of conservation). During our conference, we intend to consider these problems, seldom explored in much depth in the conservation milieu before.

A division into four thematic blocks is proposed in order to discuss the various topics during the consecutive sessions of the conference. Its programme is as follows:

Thursday 1st March – arrival of participants

Friday 2nd March – cultural programme, visit to historical monuments and museums of Florence.
h. 19.00: Evening, official opening of the conference (Auditorium al Duomo).

Saturday 3rd March – first day of conference:
- morning session
9.10 – 10.50: Values of heritage and great religious-cultural areas
11.30 - 12.50: Evolution of values and criteria
- afternoon session
15.00 – 16.00: Stystems of classification of cultural property
16.15 - 17.40: Authenticity: Outstanding Italian philosophy
18.00 - 19.20 : Values in restoration

Sunday 4th March - second day of conference:
- morning session
9.30 - 11.10: Outstanding Universal Values (OUV) - Aesthetics
11.50 - 12.40: Dilemma of values of Post-totalitarian heritage
- afternoon session
15.00 - 17.00: World heritage evaluation criteria
17.20 - 19.00: General discussion and conclusion

Monday 5th March – departure of conference participants

Thanks to the generosity of the Fondazione Romualdo Del Bianco we have been granted the best possible conditions for our deliberations and stay. The conference will take place in the very modern Auditorium al Duomo. The languages of the conference will be English and Italian with simultaneous translation. The Romualdo Del Bianco Foundation is also organizing a programme of cultural visits and thanks to the co-operation of the Monuments & Fine Arts Service it will be possible to visit the Uffizi Gallery and Vasari's Corridor.

CONDITION OF PARTICIPATION
For the invited participants selected by the co-organisers ICOMOS-ICCROM (those invited by the promoters to deliver papers and to take part in discussions) the Romualdo Del Bianco Foundation will provide hotel accommodation; the costs of travel are at participants'charge.

For the others applicants, external participants and uditors, it is requested the payment of a participation fee of Euro 350,00, V.A.T. included. The fee includes any meals, coffee breaks and receptions and dinners as par program, participation in the scientific sessions, name tag, program, symultaneous translation italian/english and english/italian.

For the accompaning persons participation, the fee is Euro 230,00, V.A.T. included. The fee covers any meals, coffee breaks and receptions and dinners as par program.

Payment must be made to:
Bank account no 000015509C00 ABI 06160 CAB 02806 CIN A
IBAN IT43A0616002806000015509C00 - BIC SWIFT CRFI IT 3F
Banca Cassa di Risparmio di Firenze, Agenzia 6, Via Nazionale 93/95 Firenze.
made out to:
Fly Events srl.
”Values and criteria in heritage preservation”
Via del Giglio n. 10 – 50123 FIRENZE - ITALIA


For any request regarding the hotel accommodation you are recommanded to ask for hotel bookings to reservations@fly-events.com which could provide for special prices for the conference.



Programme:

First draft of the programme as of 1.2.2007

Thursday 1st March – arrival of participants

Friday 2nd March – cultural programme, visit to historical monuments and museums of Florence.
h. 19.00: Evening, official opening of the conference (Auditorium al Duomo).

Saturday 3rd March – first day of conference:
- morning session
9.10 – 10.50: Values of heritage and great religious-cultural areas
11.30 - 12.50: Evolution of values and criteria
- afternoon session
15.00 – 16.00: Stystems of classification of cultural property
16.15 - 17.40: Authenticity: Outstanding Italian philosophy
18.00 - 19.20 : Values in restoration

Sunday 4th March - second day of conference:
- morning session
9.30 - 11.10: Outstanding Universal Values (OUV) - Aesthetics
11.50 - 12.40: Dilemma of values of Post-totalitarian heritage
- afternoon session
15.00 - 17.00: World heritage evaluation criteria
17.20 - 19.00: General discussion and conclusion

Monday 5th March – departure of conference participants

The topics proposed for the thematic groups require above all discussion. For this reason we envisage no more than four introductory papers of about twenty minutes in each session, the remaining time being devoted to discussion. We request all conference participants to take this into account.



 
Papers presented


Mr Gustavo Araoz
US/ICOMOS - Washington DC (USA)


Mr Giuseppe Basile
Central Institute of Restoration - Rome (Italy)


Dr. Dorothy Bell
The University of Edinburgh - Edinburgh (Scotland)


Mr CALOGERO BELLANCA
UNIVERSITY OF ROME - ROME (ITALY)


Prof. Enzo Bentivoglio
Università degli Studi Mediterranea di Reggio Calabria - Reggio Calabria (Italia)


Mr Hans Christie Bjoenness
Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Faculty of Architecture and Fine Art, Department of Urban Design and Planning - Trondheim (NORWAY)


Mr GIOVANNI BOCCARDI
UNESCO World Heritage Centre - Paris (France)


Mr MOUNIR BOUCHENAKI
ICCROM - ROME (ITALY)


Prof. Giuseppe Cruciani
Università di Firenze, Facoltà di Architettura, Dipartimento di Restauro e Conservazione dei Beni Architettonici - Firenze (Italia)


Mrs Luisa De Marco
School of Specialisation of Restoration of Monuments - Genova (Italy)


Mr JOSE MANUEL DEL RIO CARRASCO
Pont. Comm. for the Cultural Patrimony of the Church - CITTA' DEL VATICANO (CITTA' DEL VATICANO)


Mrs Susan Denyer
ICOMOS - Paris (France)


Mr. Marco Dezzi Bardeschi
ICOMOS - Italia - ( )


Mrs Natalia Dushkina
The Moscow Architectural Institute - Moscow (Russia)


Mrs Michal Firestone
ICOMOS-Israel - Jerusalem (Israel)


Mr JAVIER GALLEGO ROCA
Escuela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura UNIVERSIDAD DE GRANADA - GRANADA (SPAGNA)


Mrs Mammadova Gulchohra
Azerbaijan University of Architecture and Construction - Baku (Azerbaijan)


Mr ZHAN GUO
STATE ADMINISTRATION OF CULTURAL HERITAGE OF CHINA/ICOMOS OF CHINA - BEIJING (CHINA)


Mrs Sabina Hajiyeva
Azerbaijan University of Architecture and Construction - Baku (Azerbaijan)


Mrs Spelsberg Irmela
member of the German national committee of ICOMOS - München (Germany)


Mr Jukka Jokilehto
Private - Rome (Italy)


Mr STULC Josef
The National Institute for the Protection and Conservation of Monuments and Sites - Praha 1 (Czech Republic)


Mr Joseph King
ICCROM - Rome (Italy)


Mr Petr Kroupa
Czech National Culture Heritage Institut - Brno (Czech Republic)


Mr Marc Laenen
Centre for cultural heritage/Limburg - Hasselt (Belgium)


Mr Wilfried Lipp
ICOMOS AUSTRIA (President) - Linz (Austria)


Prof. Giorgio Macchi
University of Pavia, Faculty of Engineering, Structural Mechanics Department - Pavia (Italy)


Mr Kanefusa MASUDA
Research Center DMUCH, Ritsumeikan Univ. - Kyoto (JAPAN)


Mrs Joanne McAuley
Montagu Evans - London (London)


Mr Michael Petzet
ICOMOS International Council on monuments and Sites - Paris (France)


Prof. Giovanni Puglisi
Commissione Nazionale Italiana UNESCO - Roma (Italia)


Mr Jacek Purchla
International Cultural Centre - Krakow (Poland)


Mrs GENOVESE ROSA ANNA
UNIVERSITY "FEDERICO II" OF NAPLES / FACULTY OF ARCHITECTURE / DEPARTMENT OF ARCHITECTURAL AND ENVIRONMENTAL HERITAGE / - NAPOLI (ITALY)


Mr Andrew Sneddon
Godden Mackay Logan - Sydney (Australia)


Mrs Mehr Azar Soheil
- - - (-)


Mr NICHOLAS STANLEY-PRICE
NONE - NONE (ITALY)


Mr Bogusław Szmygin
LUBLIN UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY - LUBLIN (POLAND)


Mr dr. Fejérdy Tamás László
National Office of Hult.Heritage and ICOMOS - Budapest (Hungary)


Mrs SIMONETTA VALTIERI
UNIVERSITA' Mediterranea di REGGIO CALABRIA - Reggio Calabria (ITALY)


Mrs Meredith Walker
Australia ICOMOS - Burwood, Victoria (Australia)


Mr Gamini Wijesuriya
ICCROM - Rome (Italy)


Mrs AKIEDA Yumi Isabelle
Research Center for Disaster Mitigation of Urban Cultural Heritage, Ritsumeikan University - Kyoto (Japan)